5
edits
no edit summary
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 67: | Line 67: | ||
Overall, you've identified some real problems (and challenges) with the current state of bookmarks. There's an opportunity to make things better. I'd like to hear more details about your idea and designs, but unfortunately they are not available on this wiki as I'm writing this (date: 7 March 2011). | Overall, you've identified some real problems (and challenges) with the current state of bookmarks. There's an opportunity to make things better. I'd like to hear more details about your idea and designs, but unfortunately they are not available on this wiki as I'm writing this (date: 7 March 2011). | ||
===Eric Reiss=== | |||
I liked the statement of the problem. Jim has already pointed out some basic flaws in the presentation (e.g. the use of "of course"). But my greatest problem was that I couldn't really figure out your solution based on the deliverables presented here. The needlessly noisy video would have done better with a verbal description of what was happening on-screen instead of the irrelevant music. | |||
A short statement that described how your application has solved the basic problems of bookmarking (that links/media go out of date or cannot be bookmarked at all) would have helped a lot. Although your ideas may be great, you have simply not succeeded in proving to me that you have done something truly remarkable. | |||