9
edits
No edit summary |
JamesKalbach (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
Line 101: | Line 101: | ||
*What did you change following your user tests? | *What did you change following your user tests? | ||
Nothing yet. | Nothing yet. | ||
==Mentor Comments== | |||
===James Kalbach=== | |||
'''Concept''' | |||
* Your problem statement includes many aspects: using advanced features, organizing bookmarks in folders, and re-finding bookmarks. I’d prefer a clearer focus and statement around the issue you’re really trying to address. | |||
* Some specific examples or comparison to existing systems would help here. You just mention “the current bookmark system.” Which system? What do they have in common? Do any existing systems have strengths perhaps? | |||
* What type of research did you conduct initially and with whom? You say “most users,” which suggests some kind of quantification and generalization across a larger population. Unless you did a broader survey, you shouldn’t make such generalizations in this way. It seems you make more of an assumption, which is fine—but you should also express that way: “we assume many users typically have the problem of…” | |||
* The first sentence of your project essence is good, but the rest of it goes over the 140 character limit. | |||
'''Implementation''' | |||
* Drag and drop is fine, but have you considered accessibility issues? A visually impaired user might not be able to use your system. | |||
* Is there a limit to how many items a typical user can view and move around visually? For instance, I have hundreds of bookmarks. | |||
* The search through bookmarks is a very good idea and something browsers should already offer. | |||
* The zoom feature seems quite nice, but do you offer an alternative view of bookmarks? Sometimes a plain list works better than a spatial arrangement, and users may be seeking that. | |||
* What alternative directions did you explore before arriving at this solution? | |||
'''User tests''' | |||
* Please describe more about the tests you conducted: with whom? How many people? How long was each session? What were your key findings? |
edits